Institution-Wide Training Model
Assuming that LGBTI persons live around major urban centers, this model proposes the
training of health care workers in selected facilities favored by the LGBTI community. In the coastal region of Kenya, for example, three out of 54 health care facilities offering ARVs could be selected, in consultation with the local LGBTI community, and facility-wide sensitivity and competence training provided on a periodic basis. The main challenges of this model are the high costs of facility-wide training sessions and the need to offer continuous re-training due to high staff turnover.
Syndromic Reference Model
In this model, which replicates the Comprehensive Care Centre (CCC) model used in government facilities, only a few clinicians and counselors in selected health facilities are sensitized and
trained in the health needs of LGBTI persons. Through the use of syndromic algorithms, other health workers can then transfer patients displaying certain symptoms such as genital sores or anal infection, to competent health workers. At the same time, it can be assumed that knowledge and awareness is passed on informally among peers in selected health facilities, creating a spill-over effect. While this model has the advantage of being less costly as it does not require institution-wide training, institutional and external transfers of LGBTI-competent health workers remains a challenge. It is also dependent on the dissemination of information about the procedure among the LGBTI community.
Referral Stand-Alone Facility
This model proposes the establishment of health care desks within LGBTI community facilities where, on selected days, locum clinical officers examine, diagnose and refer patients to government health facilities for laboratory, pharmacy and other services. To reduce costs, clinic officers will be drawn from government facilities. Over time, this approach will also contribute to attitudinal change and the build-up of competence within such facilities. With the increased integration of LGBTI health services in public health facilities, stand-alone centers will eventually become abundant.
Insurance Model
This insurance-driven model aims to create incentives for private health care facilities to train their staff in LGBTI health needs in order to be considered as referral health centers for LGBTI insurance holders. While promoting sustainability and on-going innovations, this private-sector-driven model also requires profitability. Such systems could be explored through a public private partnership (PPP) pilot scheme.
Best-Practice Clinic Model
Under this model, which is used by the Fenway Institute, independent clinics are established to serve the particular health needs of LGBTI persons. These clinics can either be completely stand-alone, or they can function as specialized clinics within private hospitals, thus saving costs for shared services, such as laboratories and pharmacies. While such clinics are a good way to build much needed local competence in the area of LGBTI health services, there is also a risk that they may become stigmatized and therefore avoided by their target group. They are also cost intensive and highly localized. In order to extend their reach they must be replicated in various parts of the country. This has substantial implications in terms of cost.
Responsibility Sharing Model
In this model, responsibility for diagnosing LGBTI-specific health problems is shared between health service providers and the LGBTI community. For this to be feasible, the government must
first carry out legal and policy reforms, so that LGBTI persons are protected from discrimination in health care settings and have mechanisms for redress. Under this proviso, it becomes the responsibility of the service provider to treat LGBTI patients without stigma or discrimination. The patient, for their part, must support the health worker by speaking openly about their sexual
history and providing, where possible, additional information that can assist the clinician’s diagnosis. For example, IEC material might include a brochure or card with simple algorithms. This
could be distributed among members of the LGBTI community, who could then present it to their doctor to assist their diagnosis.
Internet Referral Model
In this model, an internet portal is set up through which LGBTI patients can consult doctors anonymously. These doctors can then issue referral notes as needed for physical examination in
selected health facilities with LGBTI-sensitized and competent health workers. A major benefit of this model is that it is simple and cost-effective to set up in the short term and could serve as
an interim solution. It could be rolled out in collaboration with one of the medical schools and consequently also provide a learning opportunity for medical students.